Excellent

Good

Average

Weak

Physical Presence

Confident and relaxed; posture and eye contact show commanding stage presence

Poised, good eye contact and posture

At times unsure, at times confident

Poor eye contact; stiff demeanor; nervous

Voice and Articulation

Very clear, crisp, well-paced, appropriate volume

Very clear, appropriate inflection, good pacing

Clear, sufficient tone, natural pacing

Inaudible; slow; distracting rhythm; singsong; hurried; mispronunciations

Appropriateness of dramatization

Well embodies poem; gestures illuminate poem’s meaning

Only gestures that enhance interpretation; embodies poem

Minimal distracting gestures or distracting voice inflection

Significant distracting gestures; inflections or accents; acting out poem; too much movement

Level of difficulty

Contains multiple elements of very challenging content, language and length

Contains multiple elements of challenging content, language and/or length

Some challenging content, language or length

Simple content, language, length

Evidence of understanding

Interprets poem very well for audience; nuanced

Well communicates meaning of poem

Satisfactorily communicates meaning of poem

Obscures meaning of poem

Overall performance

Very strong, compelling performance

Successful, enjoyable performance

Sufficient performance, nothing notable

Very weak performance; does disservice to poem